“Are we hopelessly polarized, or are we suffering from fatigue?” legendary PBS education correspondent John Merrow asks in a thoughtful blog post. “I think many of us are just tired, worn out from listening to the rants and negativity.”
What he said.
To his credit, Merrow is saying out loud what a lots of folks in the education blogosphere have been saying privately for a while now. “Debate” has become trench warfare, with the usual suspects saying the usual things, over and over, louder and louder. They’re merely getting more shrill and strident. It’s getting tedious out there. Hearts and minds are not being won.
Merrow’s no fool or squishy appeaser pleading, can’t we just get along? “Sometimes one position is correct, or largely correct. Sometimes people’s strongly held convictions are just plain wrong,” he writes.
Merrow lists several ways in which education debate is polarized: accountability, the achievement gap, school management and structures, assessment, technology, and our expectations for what we should expect of schools and teachers. Are we also polarized about the purposes of public education? Here Merrow hits his stride: “The goal of school is to help grow American citizens. Four key words: help, grow, American, citizen. Think about those words,” he writes
“Help: Schools are junior partners in education. They are to help families, the principal educators.
“Grow: It’s a process, sometimes two steps forward, one back. Education is akin to a family business, not a publicly traded stock company that lives and dies by quarterly reports.
“American: E Pluribus Unum. We are Americans, first and foremost.
“Citizen: Let’s put some flesh on that term. What do we want our children to be as adults? Good parents and neighbors, thoughtful voters, reliable workers? What else?”
“We need to get beyond polarization and figure out what we agree on,” Merrow writes. Wise and heartfelt words from one of education’s elder statesmen.